Log In


DVD Reviews

Jindabyne

Jindabyne

  • Rating: Jindabyne rated 3
  • Director: Ray Lawrence
  • Starring: Chris Haywood
  • Details: Australia / 123 mins (15A).

"We found a body. We caught the most amazing fish, though." Based on Raymond Carver's short story So Much Water So Close To Home, which got an airing in Robert Altman's Short Cuts, Lantana director Ray Lawrence switches the locale to the Australian outback and in the process changes the ethos of the story. Four fishermen from the small town of Jindabyne, New South Wales, among them Irishman Stewart Kane (Byrne), set off for their annual fishing trip in the mountains. Before he casts his first line, Stewart finds the body of an Aboriginal woman, but instead of calling the police or turning for home, the men continue fishing for a further two days, tying the woman to a tree so she won't float downstream. This callous attitude rips the town apart and puts Stewart's marriage to Claire (Linney) in jeopardy. A downbeat, low key film, Jindabyne is a slow burner, meticulously building up back story, character and interrelationships before launching into the real issue at hand: the cold nature of man, the inability to act as a human being, that people no longer care about what happens to other people. "I've no feelings one way or the other. She's dead," Stewart says. However, Lawrence ill-advisedly veers off to embrace the race issue - white man's attitude to an Aboriginal woman - and gives that the holly for the second half. The acting on show is flawless and Byrne and Linney probably haven't been better.

Review by Gavin Burke

Your Comments

No Comments have been posted for this article yet - be the first

Write Your Own Comment!

Search

Or search alphabetically:

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 0 | A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y | Z

Film Reviews

More Film

Men in Black III
FILM TITLE rated 2

Will Smith must be one of the most frustrating actors working in modern cinema. I mean, we can take Johnny Depp and his insistence on churning out the same "quirky" character, (in... [more]

Barbaric Genius
FILM TITLE rated 3.5

 We all like writers who have a bit of moxy about them, don't we? Hemmingway, Hunter Thompson, Burroughs, Bukowski. Rumour has it that when our own Mike Sheridan writes up a review he goes... [more]

A Kiss for Jed
FILM TITLE rated 2.5

Now, this could be interesting. Mark O'Halloran can write – no doubt about the talent behind Prosperity, Garage and Adam & Paul – but can he pull off playing the lead in a straight... [more]

She Monkeys
FILM TITLE rated 2

 You wait ages for an arthouse gay coming of age drama and two come along at once. And both of them crap. Coming hot on the heels of last week's disappointing Dutch drama North Sea Texas is... [more]

Your Cinema Listings

Competitions

No competitons currently running